Scotland - A History

Each month we present a chapter in the history of Scotland. We move forward in time each month.

The MacMalcolm Dynasty (continued)


The fourth of Malcolm's expeditions, in 1091, was probably the most extended, beginning in May, centring on a siege of Durham and lasting much of the summer. Although Norman retaliation again ground to its familiar halt in Lothian and a further renewal of the terms of Abernethy of 1072, the balance of power on the frontier was tilted decisively by the building of a formidable castle at Carlisle, supported by what amounted to a Norman military colony in Cumberland.8 This was not a defensive castle such as that at Newcastle but an aggressive instrument of policy of William Rufus, aimed at the soft underbelly of Malcolm's southern frontier in the west. The Norman conquest of the north-west may have had an element now lost to history, for Malcolm's reaction was not a retaliatory raid but a belated request for an audience with William Rufus at Gloucester. Whether it was a deliberate snub by William, who refused to see the King of Scots when he arrived, or the reneging by William on some part of the agreement of 1091 relating to Cumberland that provoked Malcolm into his fifth and least calculated expedition, launched into Northumbria in mid-November of 1093, is impossible to say. Both Malcolm and Edward, his eldest son by Margaret, were killed near Ainwick in an ambush. Margaret, stricken with grief, died four days later.

The legacy of Malcolm and Margaret

The conventional view of Malcolm's reign rests heavily on the influence wrought on the king by his second wife. With Margaret, the subject of the first 'official' biography of a Scottish monarch which was written by her confessor Turgot, the difficulty is to separate cult - indeed two cults - from contemporary reality. Shortly after her arrival a small Romanesque church was built at Dunfermline, the royal residence where she and Malcolm were married, and three Benedictine monks were sent at her request from the great mother house at Canterbury to form the nucleus of a Benedictine priory. It was a modest but nonetheless important first step, though in a direction which was not followed to any extent in Scotland. The beginnings of the huge, austere building (which still survives) are to be traced to its refoundation in 1128 in the reign of her youngest son, David. Yet the expansion of European monasticism, which so distinguished twelfth-century Scotland, drew not on the Benedictine impulse but on other religious orders - most notably the Augustinians or the Cistercians and Tironensians, both reformed Benedictine orders. The Life written by Turgot some twenty years after her death, touches on Dunfermline only briefly, as one of the many venues illustrating the faith and works of a deeply pious woman. Dedicated since her childhood - spent in recently converted Hungary - to 'a life of soberness' and meditation 'day and night upon the law of the Lord', her personal devotions found outlets in a renewed royal cult of St Andrew and in the patronage of eremitic monks of Loch Leven as well as in Dunfermline. Turgot describes how she supported twenty-four poor people all year round, ministered daily to nine abandoned young orphans and washed the feet of six of the poor during the seasons of Lent and Advent and had 300 more fed in the royal hall before herself.

You can find more Scottish history here.


If you are interested in ordering the resource for this material Scotland: a New History by Michael Lynch a 526 paper back book, you have two options either going through our open book to use a credit card

or you can phone or send cash by going here.

Your browser is not Java enabled.
HomeNewContentsArchivesSearchEmail

Scottish Radiance
Designed and Copyright 2003
Innovative Consulting Services, Inc.

Since January 1, 2003